Yes, I know that title is a pretty bold statement. But if you end up making these, please feel free to weigh inI have a feeling you'll agree! I make these cookies every year to give as holiday gifts to friends and family. They hold up well during shipping and actually improve in flavor and texture for up to a week. Here's my method:
I have pretty strong feelings about rugelach. I absolutely can't stand when it's dry and crumblyin my opinion, the dough should be tender and moist and filled with enough gooey, yummy morsels that they practically ooze out the sides. A few years ago it dawned on me that, when I found myself liking rugelach from a bakery, it was usually made with a cream cheese-enriched dough. The cream cheese adds that crucial tenderness and moisture.
So I set out creating my perfect Franken-recipe from several Epi versions. I used the dough from this recipe but the filling from this one. (If the choice is between a simple jam-and-raisin filling versus a chocolate and cherry one, is there even a question as to which one is better?) I rolled the rugelach into a log shape, as in the first recipe, rather than in the half-moons of the second recipe, which I felt would expose too much of the dough and filling to the drying oven heat. I used finely chopped bittersweet Valrhona chocolate rather than chocolate chips to bump up the flavor even more, and I used two to three times as much preserves, dried cherries, chocolate, and walnuts as called for. (Though there is a fine line where you cross over into too much filling, making the logs impossible to roll up. Aim for a thinly spread but even layer of preserves and a generous scattering of the other ingredients.) I brushed the cookies with cream as in the second recipe, rather than milk as in the first. (Again, no question: When is cream ever not better than milk?) And finally, I sprinkled a bit of sugar over the tops of the logs before baking, as in the first recipe.
When the logs came out of the oven, I followed the first recipe's instructions to partially cool them, then finish slicing, following the partial cuts you've made before baking. The results were incredibly moist little bundles of buttery dough, tangy sour cherries, and rich, deep bittersweet chocolate. I've made them every year since, and recipients always rave.
Anyone else like to create recipes this way, by taking desired elements from various other versions? If you're a builder of Franken-recipes, I'd love to hear about your creations.